The Guardian · 28 Sep, 10:10 · Business briefing

Job interviews are a weird business – but what’s the alternative? | Emma Beddington

Emma Beddington’s article in The Guardian critiques the conventional job interview process, describing it as an often ineffective and awkward mechanism for assessing candidate suitability.

What it means for you ↓ Courses for this story

26%average salary uplift after a professional certificate

2.7xfaster promotion for certified professionals

71%of leaders prefer candidates who upskill continuously

20days to your first credential

The briefing

The story
in brief.

What happened, who it affects, and why it landed on our intelligence desk — in plain English, sixty seconds or less.

Emma Beddington’s article in The Guardian critiques the conventional job interview process, describing it as an often ineffective and awkward mechanism for assessing candidate suitability. The piece questions the validity of traditional face-to-face or virtual interviews, suggesting they may not accurately predict job performance. It explores potential alternatives to this entrenched hiring practice, highlighting the disconnect between interview performance and actual workplace capability. The report invites readers to consider how organisations might evolve their recruitment strategies to move beyond this 'weird business' and adopt more meaningful evaluation methods.

Employer demand for AI in Recruitment skills — indexed growth since 2019
Indicative index of skill mentions in professional job postings for the field this story moves (2019 = 1)

Your move

What this means
for your career.

Every headline redistributes opportunity. Here is who this one rewards — and how to be on the right side of it.

This shift signals a move away from performance-based interviewing toward evidence-based assessment. As traditional interviews lose credibility, skills in structured evaluation and unbiased selection rise in value. You should pay close attention if you work in talent acquisition or senior hiring roles. A smart professional would immediately audit their current hiring metrics, looking for bias or poor predictive validity. You must upskill in modern recruitment technologies and data-driven selection methods. Focus on understanding how to assess competence through work samples or structured behavioural assessments rather than conversational charm. Prepare to advocate for pilot programmes that test alternative hiring models within your organisation. This is your opportunity to lead the change toward fairer, more effective talent acquisition processes.

For this story, the fields that convert it into pay are AI in Recruitment, Human Resources, Business and Management and Psychology — exactly the programmes matched below. The chart shows the indicative salary uplift certified professionals report in each of those fields; every one of them is a click away, from £79, finishing in as few as 20 days.

Indicative salary uplift in the fields matched to this story
Indicative ranges from published continuing-education salary studies, by field — each field is a recommended course below

Matched to this story

Enrol in these
to benefit.

These programmes position you for exactly this shift — online, self-paced, and finishing with a verifiable certificate you can share the day you pass.